About the 3-Sieve Particle Size Analysis Method
The 3-sieve particle size analysis method was developed by researchers at Kansas State University to provide a quick and accurate way to estimate particle size in feed mills without the time and expense required for the standard 12-sieve analysis.
Research Validation
A 2015 study evaluated the accuracy of the 3-sieve method by comparing it to the standard 12-sieve method using 420 grain samples. The research tested various factors:
- Three grain types (corn, sorghum, wheat)
- Two top sieve sizes (U.S. No. 12 vs. No. 16)
- Flow agent usage (0 vs. 0.5g)
- Technician variation (three different technicians)
Key Findings
- The original 3-sieve method accurately predicts particle size to within 15 μm of the standard method
- Technician variation had minimal impact (maximum deviation of 5.1 μm)
- Top sieve size didn’t significantly affect accuracy
- Flow agent didn’t improve method accuracy
- Grain type showed slight differences in accuracy:
- Underestimated corn by ~12 μm
- Overestimated wheat by ~15 μm
- Accurately measured sorghum (within 0.1 μm)
Valid Range
The 3-sieve method has been proven robust for particle sizes from 200 to 900 μm across corn, sorghum, and wheat.